Would you sell

[cj10jeeper]

I’d certainly condense to 1 car given the mileage and in any event not 2 sports cars.
Cayman is a great car and am sure you’ll enjoy it, but similar to others I’ve never beeen a porker fan. That’s the personal choice decision

[andyfanshawe]

having 1 car makes more sense but I don't like porkers so its personal choice

I've got 5!

Youngest is 11 years old (Z4 and my trusty fiesta).
Camaro 26 years old.
Crown vic 27 years old
Jag x type estate (not dirty diesel..yuk) 12 years old.

Who needs new cars? Not me.

Andy.

[Mr Tidy]

Way too many BMW's coming through my workshop doors over last few months. Same problems everytime (almost!). Fickle fragile little beasts they are. Although LR discovery/freelanders give them a run for their money!!

Andy.

That's interesting OP - could you maybe expand on that a bit, for the benefit of those of us who still love our BMWs?

[andyfanshawe]

Without being too model specific, but i'll try.....
1 series (including 2013, 2014 models) and others, timing chains, differential that make horrible noises, ABS reluctor/toothed wheels that corrode and expand and rub the end off the abs sensors (including Z4), any model BMW with valvetronic motors (now down to < £285 at the dealers), vanos seals, window motor regulators, usual Z4 sticky steering, ABS/DSC modules on a lot of models, usual DISA, Many, many vacuum leaks (usually from PCV system hose deterioration), lollipop bushes. Having a run on E85/86 z4 starter motors at the moment, but the cars are getting old now!!

I went over to Warrington recently, over pennines from me, to see a 2012 1 series 116i. Not a short journey, and it was horrible (the journey and the car). Written off twice in first year and a half of its life, 4 different tyres, all 4 alloys kerbed, drivetrain fault and in limited power mode (didn't find out why), interior worn to hell, seats faded, rear discs well worn (but seller said "it passed an MOT with them"). Even the key fob was worn and tatty. And only done 49000 miles apparently.

There are undoubtedly really good ones out there, but I only see the poorly ones. Gives a very biased impression in my head, which is sometimes hard to get rid of.

I can understand why people buy them though. Quite attractive and generate loyal followers.

Shall I buy another BMW? Never say never, but probably not.
i get asked many, many times what reliable car I would recommend buying since I am in the trade. My answer?...... None. Get a pushbike instead.

Andy.

[Paulr]

I have the Z4 , but as I tow, carry 16 foot open boats, and tons of wet kayaking gear for me and Scouts, I need an older bigger 4x4. If I could find a way of carrying the boats on the Zed I could get rid of the Sata Fe.

[Paulr]

I have the Z4 , but as I tow, carry 16 foot open boats, and tons of wet kayaking gear for me and Scouts, I need an older bigger 4x4. If I could find a way of carrying the boats on the Zed I could get rid of the Sata Fe.

[Angelus666]

Given how little mileage you're doing then why not an M Coupe...got to be more interesting for those 4k miles than the Cayman....but maybe not the 'better' car.

[Havard]

Given how little mileage you're doing then why not an M Coupe...got to be more interesting for those 4k miles than the Cayman....but maybe not the 'better' car.

This..!! Having both has certainly opened my eyes. Looking forward to getting out in the M tomorrow.

H.

[Mr Tidy]

Without being too model specific, but i'll try.....
1 series (including 2013, 2014 models) and others, timing chains, differential that make horrible noises, ABS reluctor/toothed wheels that corrode and expand and rub the end off the abs sensors (including Z4), any model BMW with valvetronic motors (now down to < £285 at the dealers), vanos seals, window motor regulators, usual Z4 sticky steering, ABS/DSC modules on a lot of models, usual DISA, Many, many vacuum leaks (usually from PCV system hose deterioration), lollipop bushes. Having a run on E85/86 z4 starter motors at the moment, but the cars are getting old now!!

I went over to Warrington recently, over pennines from me, to see a 2012 1 series 116i. Not a short journey, and it was horrible (the journey and the car). Written off twice in first year and a half of its life, 4 different tyres, all 4 alloys kerbed, drivetrain fault and in limited power mode (didn't find out why), interior worn to hell, seats faded, rear discs well worn (but seller said "it passed an MOT with them"). Even the key fob was worn and tatty. And only done 49000 miles apparently.

There are undoubtedly really good ones out there, but I only see the poorly ones. Gives a very biased impression in my head, which is sometimes hard to get rid of.

I can understand why people buy them though. Quite attractive and generate loyal followers.

Shall I buy another BMW? Never say never, but probably not.
i get asked many, many times what reliable car I would recommend buying since I am in the trade. My answer?...... None. Get a pushbike instead.

Andy.

Thanks, that is interesting!

But then I had to put a new radiator in a 7 year old MKII RS2000.

And a new (mechanical) water pump in a Capri 2.8i at 8 years old.

Plus a new ECU for the "drive by wire" accelerator on a C280 Mercedes at 7 years old.

So outside of the warranty they can all be potential disasters - mind you I am still glad I sold my 123d at 81K miles before the cam-chain failed (as that was before BMW started paying for them)!

To be fair the 116i you went to see sounds like a shed, but that seems to be more down to the owners than the manufacturer.

By way of comparison my E46 made it to 13 years old before it needed a radiator, and my first E86 got to 10 years before the (electric) water pump died!

BMWs are no worse for failures than others, but IME they seem to last a bit longer before it happens!

[TitanTim]

Keep both and get another car

Tim.

[MACK]

Test drive and go from there really, see how you feel then.

There's no doubt the Boxster/Cayman are better to drive, but that comes at a cost both in terms of initial outlay and ongoing cost. Its years since I drove either a Z4M or a 987s. One thing I seem to remember is the Z4M seemed to have a bit more grunt, particularly low down the revs.
I'm not sure that I share the sentiment that the Cayman will hold their valve long term either. The early ones are starting to dip under £10k and I know that they can have engine issues that hopefully wont blight the 987 Gen 2 ones, but the real question is how low will they go. Will they follow the original Boxster into absolute peanuts territory for example.
Another thing I would consider is holding off another 12 months or so and the start thinking 718 instead.

Can I ask why not sell the Audi anyway and just use the Z4M with such a low combined mileage. Probably do it some good to have a bit more regular use and if the Audi's value is still heading south bank the cash for future use.

[paddy wright]

My z has been my baby for nearly 10 years and I'll never sell. Depends on your situation but for the small value in a z I would never consider parting with mine despite doing about 1K a year in him!

[LeeZ4MR]

I think I`d keep the two you have because its nice to swap and change, having just one car no matter how special it is can lose its specialness if its used day in day out, or you don't have anything to compare it to.